Many young Austrians start their investment journey with the bank their parents use. Erste Bank, with its ubiquitous presence and trusted brand, seems like the natural choice. But a growing number of investors under 30 are discovering that tradition comes at a steep price, one that neobrokers have eliminated entirely.
The Breaking Point: When Loyalty Costs You Money
The frustration typically begins with a simple transaction. You buy a few shares of an ETF, expecting to pay a small fee. Instead, Erste Bank charges order fees that can reach double digits. Then come the quarterly depotgebühren (depot fees), automatically deducted even if you don’t trade. For investors under 27, these fees should theoretically be waived, yet many report charges appearing on their statements without clear explanation.
One investor’s experience illustrates the pattern: despite being under 27, he faced quarterly depotgebühren starting in 2025. When he tried to cancel his depot in December, the bank claimed his cancellation letter was “lost.” In January, they demanded full fees for the first quarter of 2026. This isn’t an isolated incident, it’s a systemic issue that pushes young Austrians toward alternatives.
The real kicker comes during depot transfers. Traditional banks often cannot provide the Einstandskurs (cost basis) for your positions, creating tax headaches down the line. When you eventually sell, you’ll struggle to calculate your capital gains correctly for the Finanzamt (Tax Office).
The Neobroker Alternative: Zero Fees, Full Control
Neobrokers have inverted the traditional banking model completely. Trade Republic, Scalable Capital, and Finanzen.net Zero offer depotgebührenfrei (free depot management) as a baseline. Their business models rely on volume and premium services rather than nickel-and-diming every customer.
Cost Comparison for a Young Investor:
- Erste Bank: 2.95€ monthly depot fee + 9.95€+ per order
- Trade Republic: 0€ depot fee + 1€ per order (ETF sparpläne free)
- Scalable Capital: 0€ depot fee + 0.99€ per order (ETF sparpläne free)
- Finanzen.net Zero: 0€ depot fee + 0€ per order (with spreads)
For someone investing 100€ monthly, Erste Bank’s fees could eat 10-15% of your investment. With Trade Republic, you keep nearly everything.
The difference isn’t just monetary. Neobrokers provide instant execution through mobile apps, while traditional banks still rely on paper forms and branch visits for many operations. When you need support, neobrokers offer chat support that actually solves problems rather than deflecting them.
Why Erste Bank Can’t Compete
Erste Bank, like most traditional Austrian banks, operates with a kostenstruktur (cost structure) built for a pre-digital era. They maintain hundreds of physical branches, pay staff salaries, and run legacy IT systems. These kosten (costs) get passed to customers through fees that neobrokers simply don’t have.
More critically, traditional banks view brokerage as a secondary service. Their primary business remains girokonten (checking accounts) and loans. Investment services exist to cross-sell, not to excel. This explains why their trading platforms feel like afterthoughts and why customer service agents seem trained to discourage active trading.
The numbers reveal the gap: while Erste Bank offers around 150-200 ETFs, Scalable Capital provides over 2,700. Trade Republic covers 2,600+ ETFs with commission-free sparpläne (savings plans). For young investors building diversified portfolios, the choice is obvious.
The Tax Trap No One Warns You About
Here’s where the neobroker advantage becomes decisive. Austrian tax law requires precise documentation of purchase prices for the kest (capital gains tax). When traditional banks fail to transfer this data, you face hours of reconstructing transactions through Finanzonline, the tax portal.
Neobrokers digitize this process. They maintain complete transaction histories exportable in formats compatible with Austrian tax software. Some even integrate directly with tax preparation tools. For expats and international residents already navigating complex steuerpflicht (tax obligations), this digital clarity is invaluable.
The Hidden Cost of “Free” Banking
Erste Bank and other traditional institutions often waive depotgebühren for young customers initially, but with conditions. You might need to maintain a minimum balance, execute a certain number of trades, or hold other products. Fail to meet these, and fees appear retroactively.
Neobrokers typically offer genuinely free accounts with no hidden conditions. Their revenue comes from optional premium features, payment for order flow, or small spreads, not from penalizing inactive customers.
How to Make the Switch
Switching from Erste Bank to a neobroker requires careful steps to avoid tax complications:
-
Open your neobroker account first: Complete the VideoIdent (video identification) process, which takes about 10 minutes through your smartphone.
-
Initiate the depotübertrag (depot transfer): Request this through your neobroker. They’ll handle the paperwork with Erste Bank. Never close your old depot before the transfer completes.
-
Document everything: Screenshot your current positions and purchase prices from Erste Bank’s portal before initiating the transfer. If they lose data, you’ll have proof.
-
Watch for the übertrag (transfer): This can take 2-4 weeks. During this time, you cannot trade the affected positions.
-
Verify cost basis: Once transferred, immediately verify that your neobroker shows correct purchase prices. If not, contact support with your documentation.
-
Close the old depot formally: Send a written kündigung (cancellation) via Einschreiben (registered mail) to create a paper trail.
The Bigger Picture: A Generational Shift
This exodus reflects more than just fee sensitivity. Young Austrian investors grew up with digital services that work seamlessly. They expect the same from financial institutions. When Erste Bank’s online portal crashes or requires multiple authentications for simple tasks, while Trade Republic executes trades in seconds, the choice becomes cultural, not just financial.
The trend mirrors broader European banking shifts. In Germany, Sparkassen face similar challenges. In Austria, Raiffeisen and Bank Austria experience identical customer losses. The entire traditional banking sector risks losing a generation of investors who equate “bank” with “unnecessary cost and hassle.”
What Erste Bank Could Do
To stem the outflow, Erste Bank would need to:
– Eliminate depotgebühren entirely for customers under 35
– Reduce order fees to maximum 2€ per transaction
– Modernize their mobile app to neobroker standards
– Guarantee complete data transfer during depotübertrag
– Offer genuine digital customer service
But institutional inertia makes this unlikely. Their business model depends on fee income from traditional services. Matching neobroker pricing would require restructuring their entire operation.
Bottom Line for Young Austrian Investors
If you’re under 30 and investing through Erste Bank, you’re almost certainly paying too much. The combination of depotgebühren, high order costs, and poor digital experience creates a significant drag on your returns.
The research is clear: neobrokers like Trade Republic and Scalable Capital offer superior service at near-zero cost. They understand that young investors want mobile-first, transparent, low-cost solutions. Traditional banks treat investment accounts as profit centers, neobrokers treat them as core products.
Before your next quarterly statement arrives with another unexpected fee, consider opening a neobroker account. Your future self, reviewing your jährliche Steuererklärung (annual tax return) with clean, complete digital records, will thank you.
The banking loyalty your parents practiced made sense in an era of limited choice. Today, staying with Erste Bank for investments is like using a fax machine when email exists, nostalgic, but expensive and inefficient.
